Neil Simon’s The Odd Couple opened Friday evening at Village Square Theatre in Lexington, bringing laughter, nostalgia, and a delightful dose of 1960s charm to the stage. Under the sharp direction of Allison McNeely, this production captures the timeless humor and heart of Simon’s beloved play while offering a fresh, lively take on the story of two polar-opposite roommates. From the first moments, the show delivers exactly what audiences hope for—snappy dialogue, hilarious physical comedy, and a genuine sense of camaraderie among its cast.
Director Allison McNeely has crafted a production that feels both authentic and full of energy. Her attention to pacing and character dynamics keeps the comedy crisp without losing the play’s warmth. The 1960s setting is beautifully realized—Dell Goodrich’s costume design perfectly captures the era’s style, from the guys’ sloppy dress to the mod dresses and shoes for the girls, and the set transports the audience straight into Oscar Madison’s cluttered New York apartment. It’s clearly a labor of love, with many members of the cast and crew contributing to its creation. Every detail, from the furniture to the period-appropriate props, feels thoughtfully chosen and true to the time.
While the production was strong overall, there were a few technical hiccups with the wireless microphones on opening night. But that’s live theatre—anything can happen—and the cast handled it with professionalism and ease, never breaking character or losing momentum. In fact, the moments when the mics faltered proved that the actors didn’t need them; their projection and clarity carried beautifully across the intimate space. In smaller venues like Village Square, strong vocal work often serves better than amplification, and this cast proved that point with confidence.
The cast of The Odd Couple was uniformly strong, led by David LaTorre as the neurotic Felix Ungar and Davis Herndon as the lovable slob Oscar Madison. LaTorre fully embodied Felix’s nervous energy—his fussy mannerisms, anxious pacing, and relentless tidying perfectly captured the character’s comic tension. Herndon, by contrast, brought an easy charm to Oscar, a man who lives for poker nights, cold beer, and controlled chaos. Together, the two actors found a natural rhythm, their chemistry and timing making the famous odd pairing feel both believable and fresh.
Adding to the fun were the delightfully ditzy Pigeon sisters, played by Ivy Munnerlin (Cecily) and Melissa Frierson (Gwendolyn). Their infectious giggling and lively energy lit up the stage, serving as a perfect foil to Felix’s nervous breakdown and Oscar’s barely contained frustration. The result was comedy gold.
Oscar’s poker pals added another layer of humor and heart to the production. Clayton King, Charles Zuber, Steve Reeves, and newcomer Cole Allen created a believable band of mismatched friends who clearly enjoy one another’s company—both onstage and off. Each brought a distinct personality to the table: the sarcastic wit, the mild-mannered pushover, the no-nonsense realist, and the good-natured joker. Their overlapping dialogue and easy camaraderie made the poker scenes feel wonderfully natural, as if the audience were eavesdropping on a real group of lifelong friends ribbing each other through a Friday night game. Their chemistry grounded the show and reminded us why The Odd Couple continues to resonate—because friendships, however messy, are what make life bearable.
In the end, Village Square Theatre’s The Odd Couple delivers exactly what audiences come to the theatre for—a night of laughter, nostalgia, and genuine connection. Under Allison McNeely’s direction, the cast brings Neil Simon’s iconic characters to life with heart and humor, reminding us why this play remains a timeless classic. Whether you’re a longtime fan of The Odd Couple or discovering it for the first time, this production is a delightful reminder that even the most mismatched friendships can endure. It’s smart, funny, and filled with charm—an evening well spent at Village Square Theatre.
The show will run through November 2, so hurry and get your tickets before they are gone. You can purchase them online at villagesquaretheatre.com.
***