REVIEW: Chapin Theatre Company's Nana's Naughty Knickers is Less Naughty and More Hilarious

By Cindi Boiter

If you’re in the market for a fun evening – and if you aren’t you really should be – head out to Chapin Theatre Company for a night of all around fun with Nana’s Naughty Knickers, by Katherine DiSaviro and directed by Jane Peterson. The play is fun, the opening announcement is fun, some of the cast bios in the playbill are surprisingly fun, the actors are having fun and judging by the sold-out reception to Thursday’s opening night, the audience can’t help but have fun.

But don’t let the fun-for-all muddle your perception. This play is well done and the cast and crew have something to be proud of. Casting for this production was spot-on, led by Sandy Steffen in the role of Nana, aka Sylvia Charles; Debra Haines Kiser, who was made for the role of Sylvia’s BFF Vera Walters; and Ella Riley, who impresses me more and more every time I see her perform, playing Sylvia’s granddaughter Bridget who is staying the summer in New York City with her Nana before starting law school.

The interaction between these three women was, to put it in technical terms, a hoot! Kiser is one of the funniest people I have seen in a live performance, and she is unfailingly committed to her role. I’m always baffled by how real pros keep a straight face doing ridiculous things. But Kiser has a lock on this challenge. Steffen and Riley never break either, despite the abject silliness happening around them. Special kudos to Riley who not only has to wear an absolutely ridiculous example of Nana’s naughty knickers later in the play—certainly, a challenge to the ego of a beautiful young woman—but she also has to repeatedly exchange socks with Kiser in front of the live audience. Hint: she’s not putting them on her feet. If you know you know, or if you were ever a flat-chested teenage girl, you might know, too.

Supporting roles include that of Tom O’Grady, a NYC cop played by Andy Blackwell (don’t miss reading his playbill bio) and greedy landlord Gil Schmidt, played by Manny Moitoso, both of whom pulled off their performances without a hitch. Aurora Gastright and Beth DeHart show up in the second act looking sassy, and UPS men Charles Garren and Christian Banks show up looking like UPS men, which was their jobs.

DeHart also served as assistant director to Peterson while Cindy Binnicker served as her stage manager. Peterson gives both women ample props in her director’s note. But it sounds like Set Design was a team effort, given the many surprises the set requires. Hats off to Jim DeFelice, Tiffany Dinsmore, Michael Gastright, Len Lesslie, Tyler Zangla, Tom Kline, Chris Whitehead, and Jane Peterson for their successful efforts.

A note about the PG-13 rating for Nana’s Naughty Knickers: While this is not necessarily a play for children, there is nothing really naughty about the content of this play. The concept is that an elderly woman—someone’s grandmother—is making extra cash by designing and selling “sexy lingerie” for other elderly women. The outfits we see are only sexy in theory; they are actually quite humorous  with the exception of Heather Van Pree’s costume, which is a bit racy, but this reviewer’s take on Aurora Gastright’s gum-popping performance in that costume is that she was adorable. Sure, there is cleavage at play here but many women are completely comfortable wearing far more suggestive fashions to dinner and a movie. The play was published in 2010 and might could use a light update, to be honest. That said, I think many children under 13 could see and enjoy the hysterics of the play (especially the set design) without ever noticing the implication of sauciness. I’d definitely take my 6-year-old grandkid.

Nana’s Naughty Knickers plays at Chapin Theatre Company at 830 Columbia Avenue in Chapin May 14 – 31. For times and tickets, which are selling fast, we hear, visit the CTC website.

(Full disclosure: Jane Peterson is a member of the board of directors for the Jasper Project and Theatre Editor for Jasper Magazine. She, and her dedication to the work, is also the reason Jasper has been able to review so many more plays under her direction. Please know that we did attempt to find a reviewer without ties to Jasper but were unable to. So, rather than opting not to review Nana, this reviewer stepped in and tried her best to remain objective. Also, if you are a theatre person with a critical eye we’d love to talk to you about reviewing local theatre for Jasper.)

Meet Clayton King -- One of the Stars of Busted Open, Jasper's 2025 Play Right Series Winning Play by Ryan Stevens

We’re introducing the cast of Jasper’s 5th annual Play Right Series winning play, Busted Open, directed by Jane Turner Peterson. You’ve met Ella Riley, Zanna Mills, Beth DeHart, Kristin Cobb, and Allison Allgood already. Now meet Clayton King who plays the role of Phil in this brand new play written by SC playwright Ryan Stevens.

Join us at Columbia Music Festival Association on Sunday afternoon, September 14th at 3 pm for the premiere staged reading of this fresh new theatre art! Tickets are only $10 and are on sale now!

Clayton King (Phil) is excited to be part of the Jasper Project play Busted Open. He is a Texas transplant, calling Columbia home for more than a decade. Both a producer and performer, Clayton has more than 75 stage credits to his name and has performed with Midlands Light Opera Society, Broadway Bound Vista Theatre Project, Chapin Community Theatre, Town Theatre, Trustus, Village Square, and Workshop Theatre. Some credits include Pirates of Penzance (Major General Stanley), Secret Garden (Neville), Shrek (Shrek), Into the Woods (Baker), She Loves Me! (Mr. Maraczek); Mamma Mia! (Harry Bright), Arsenic and Old Lace (Teddy), You Can’t Take It With You (Kohlenkov), The Addams Family (Gomez), Guys & Dolls (Nathan Detroit). Clayton was voted Best Actor in the Free-Times Best of Columbia who noted “[Clayton is] a vocal powerhouse who can handle both comedic and dramatic roles with aplomb.”

Before leaving Texas Clayton appeared on stage in productions of Damn Yankees and Chicago at Galveston’s historic The Grand 1894 Opera House, A Fiddler on the Roof at the historic Strand Street Theatre and The Wind and the Willows at Houston’s Theatre Under the Stars. 

In addition to character roles on stage, Clayton is a prolific cabaret performer in venues along the Texas Gulf (of Mexico!) coast and across the Midlands. He cut his teeth in this medium while attending the University of Houston and developed his artistry with small venue performance in such notable cabaret spots as Houston’s Baha Sams and the unlikely-named Million Dollar Dump. When not in a production or working at his “day job” as Parish Administrator at St. Martin’s-in-the-Fields Episcopal church, he balances his dual alter egos: 1) a singer as one of ten cabaret artists who perform in The Monthly After Dinner Cabaret, a series he and Vicky Saye [Henderson] produce under the banner of King Henderson Productions, which will relaunch in October, 2025. 2) A jewelry and home accessory designer. Both feed his soul and provide a certain type of therapy in these trying times.