REVIEW: A Heartfelt and Hilarious Start: Second Samuel Kicks Off Columbia Soda City Theatre’s First Season by Jane Turner Peterson

Second Samuel is the kind of show that reminds you why community theatre matters. It makes you laugh, makes you think, and makes you feel connected — to the characters, to the town, and to each other. -JTP

Columbia’s newest theatre company has officially arrived — and what a debut! Located inside Brookland United Methodist Church in West Columbia, Soda City Theatre launches its very first season on a high note with Second Samuel, delivering a show that’s both laugh-out-loud funny and surprisingly moving.

Directed by Jeff Sigley, Pamela Parker’s Second Samuel takes us to a small Georgia town in the 1940s, where life seems simple… until it isn’t. When a beloved resident, Miss Gertrude, passes away, her friends and neighbors discover a secret that rocks their little community to its core.

This play may be set in another time, but its themes are as relevant as ever. One of the cast members, Ripley Thames, summed it up perfectly — Second Samuel touches on “the trifecta” of issues that still challenge us today: homophobia, racism, and prejudice toward people with disabilities. And somehow, the show manages to explore all of that with humor, warmth, and a whole lot of heart.

Sigley’s direction really shines here. He uses the stage cleverly to create three locations — the Bait and Brew, the beauty salon, and Miss Gertrude’s front porch — and the smooth scene transitions, supported by smart lighting, keep things flowing beautifully. The set design makes great use of the space, and the period-appropriate costumes and props (kudos to Joanne Shaw and team!) really help transport the audience to the 1940s.

Now, let’s talk about this cast — because hats off here.

First, keep an eye on Cash Conroy. His performance as B Flat, the young autistic man who narrates the story, is simply stunning. He brings so much heart and honesty to the role, guiding the audience through the story with charm and depth. It’s no surprise he’s already been in several local youth productions — this young actor is definitely going places.

The rest of the cast is just as strong. Debra Leopard is a joy as Omaha Nebraska — her timing is impeccable, and it’s wonderful to see her back on stage. Nathan Wright had the audience in stitches as June Cline, the town caretaker, with his expressive reactions and storytelling flair. Ripley Thames made Mr. Mozel perfectly intolerable (in the best way), and Bill Arvay brought a grounded, easy energy as Doc.

In the beauty shop scenes, Gayle Stewart (Marcella) and Ginny Walker (Ruby) were a hoot, trading zingers, and sass with Tammy Smith as the bigoted Jimmie Dean. And rounding out the Bait and Brew gang — Roderick Haynes (U.S.), Mark DiNovo (Frisky), and Barry Smith (Mansel) — each added their own spark to the mix.

All in all, Second Samuel is the kind of show that reminds you why community theatre matters. It makes you laugh, makes you think, and makes you feel connected — to the characters, to the town, and to each other.

If this production is any indication, Soda City Theatre has an exciting road ahead. Here’s to a fantastic start and many more stories to come!

Catch Second Samuel at Columbia Soda City Theatre before it’s gone. Performances run November 8, 13-15 at 7:30 pm and on Sunday, Nov. 9 at 3:00 pm. For tickets and more information, please visit their website at sodacitytheatre.com.

A heart-warming tour of "Second Samuel" - a review of the new show at On Stage Productions

There may be snow and ice across most of the southeast, but there is warmth to spare in the little town of Second Samuel, GA (so named after the Yankees burned the first town down) where colorful Southern eccentricity blends with a timely message of tolerance and acceptance. Pamela Parker's Second Samuel has been produced at dozens of theatres, from Wetumpka, AL, to Perth, Australia, and off-Broadway by this production's director, Robert Harrelson. Harrelson, the founder of On Stage Productions in West Columbia, has a nice little under-the-radar hit on his hands, and it only runs through this Sunday at the On Stage Performance Center, at 680 Cherokee Rd.

Our narrator and tour guide is B-Flat (Sam Edelson), an appealing, innocent young man (or older teen) given his ironic nickname by piano teacher Miss Gertrude for his lack of musical ability. (His actual surname is "Flatt," first initial "B.") B-Flat is just a little slow, or what they used to call "simple" in the play's 1949 setting. Think Jethro from The Beverly Hillbillies, or Eb from Green Acres, just more loveable. As played by Edelson, one imagines that B-Flat is probably just awkward and perhaps dyslexic, with minimal education. His description of his hometown's quirks is fairly eloquent and insightful, in the manner of Big River's Huck (another under-educated outcast thought to be simple), and one local accurately observes that the boy may have more sense than anyone else. Plus his big heart makes up for any intellectual shortcomings. Like Steel Magnolias, the local ladies gather to chat at the beauty parlor, while the men convene at "Frisky's Bait and Brew," the kind of place where you can get a Nehi and a Moon Pie as easily as a cold beer or a shot of whiskey. Every character would be at home in Mayberry, Hooterville, or Faulkner's Yoknapatawpha County. I mention these iconic rural settings from fiction not to imply that author Parker is necessarily influenced by them, but rather to note that she is working in an easily recognizable tradition, with all the stock character types - archetypes even - that we expect. What she does with them, however, is quite creative, and caught me completely by surprise.

1949 was the summer that the beloved Miss Gertrude died, and the play's action commences with preparations for her funeral, as everyone recalls how she touched so many lives in some way. Assorted plot twists transpire, taking the broad, southern-fried comedy of the first act into slightly more serious and meaningful territory in the second. Hilarious characters still are funny, but they face decisions that will define just who they are, both as individuals and as a community. A good parallel might be socially conscious sitcoms from the 70's like All in the Family, or warm family-themed shows from the 80's (e.g. Family Ties or The Golden Girls) where outrageous characters engage in outlandish antics, but there's still an "Awwwww" moment at the end.

A friend noted that everyone seemed perfect for his or her role. A few of the cast are clearly newer to acting, while some have been shining in lead roles for decades, especially at community theatres in Lexington and Chapin, but everyone plays a specific type convincingly. Parker's dialogue flows very naturally, and all the cast has to do is go where the words take them. Debra Leopard and MJ Maurer are especially convincing as histrionic ladies with big hair, while Courtney Long as pretty young Ruby has fewer lines, but is always enaged in the action on stage. As Leopard and Maurer squabble with the town troublemaker (Anne Snider) Long is giggling silently at every word, indicating how seriously the audience should take them. David Reed as the local funeral director has some inspired comic moments. Full disclosure: he and I did a show together 20+ years ago, and so I am familiar with his real voice and mannerisms. Here he affects the soft, high voice of a prim Southern gentleman, and creates a very believable character. Some of the show's biggest laughs come from physical comedy where Reed is drinking, while the beauty parlor ladies are screaming: everyone's pace and pitch is perfect, while Brandon Moore's split-second timing on light cues makes everything flow at a lively pace. Also deserving of praise is the sincerity that A.T. Marion brings to the pivotal role of "U.S." In rural 1949 Georgia, the challenges faced by U.S. as a person of color are obvious, and Parker never sugar-coats the historical context. U.S. wisely explains to B-Flat that each of them is different, but then, who isn't in some way? The charm of the town, and the play, is the way in which the town's residents ultimately look out for their friends. (They even pretend to believe the man who swears he was kidnapped by Nazis from a U-boat off Myrtle Beach , when everyone knows this was a story concocted to explain a week-long bender.)

The space at On Stage, a former retail shop that probably specialized in country-western attire, is limited, and director Harrelson does an excellent job of blocking, given the close quarters. More importantly, he has cast the right types to bring out the depth and nuances of the work, which can be enjoyed at face value as a variation on Mayberry or Vicky Lawrence's Momma's Family, or taken at a much deeper level.

On Stage Productions is now in its fourth season (see the current print issue of Jasper - vol. 3 no. 3 - for some details on its origin) and is a wonderful little gem that's not nearly as out of the way as you might think. From downtown Columbia, you simply cross the Blossom St. bridge and head out Charleston Highway, veering on to Airport Blvd. Cherokee Lane is the right just before I-26, which it parallels, and you're there in not much more than 5 minutes. When my friend Melissa saw and reviewed their last production, her young daughter told her "This looks like a fun place to do a show," and I heartily agree.

Second Samuel runs through Sunday, Feb. 16th - visit http://www.onstagesc.com for ticket information.

~ August Krickel