REVIEW: A Heartfelt and Hilarious Start: Second Samuel Kicks Off Columbia Soda City Theatre’s First Season by Jane Turner Peterson

Second Samuel is the kind of show that reminds you why community theatre matters. It makes you laugh, makes you think, and makes you feel connected — to the characters, to the town, and to each other. -JTP

Columbia’s newest theatre company has officially arrived — and what a debut! Located inside Brookland United Methodist Church in West Columbia, Soda City Theatre launches its very first season on a high note with Second Samuel, delivering a show that’s both laugh-out-loud funny and surprisingly moving.

Directed by Jeff Sigley, Pamela Parker’s Second Samuel takes us to a small Georgia town in the 1940s, where life seems simple… until it isn’t. When a beloved resident, Miss Gertrude, passes away, her friends and neighbors discover a secret that rocks their little community to its core.

This play may be set in another time, but its themes are as relevant as ever. One of the cast members, Ripley Thames, summed it up perfectly — Second Samuel touches on “the trifecta” of issues that still challenge us today: homophobia, racism, and prejudice toward people with disabilities. And somehow, the show manages to explore all of that with humor, warmth, and a whole lot of heart.

Sigley’s direction really shines here. He uses the stage cleverly to create three locations — the Bait and Brew, the beauty salon, and Miss Gertrude’s front porch — and the smooth scene transitions, supported by smart lighting, keep things flowing beautifully. The set design makes great use of the space, and the period-appropriate costumes and props (kudos to Joanne Shaw and team!) really help transport the audience to the 1940s.

Now, let’s talk about this cast — because hats off here.

First, keep an eye on Cash Conroy. His performance as B Flat, the young autistic man who narrates the story, is simply stunning. He brings so much heart and honesty to the role, guiding the audience through the story with charm and depth. It’s no surprise he’s already been in several local youth productions — this young actor is definitely going places.

The rest of the cast is just as strong. Debra Leopard is a joy as Omaha Nebraska — her timing is impeccable, and it’s wonderful to see her back on stage. Nathan Wright had the audience in stitches as June Cline, the town caretaker, with his expressive reactions and storytelling flair. Ripley Thames made Mr. Mozel perfectly intolerable (in the best way), and Bill Arvay brought a grounded, easy energy as Doc.

In the beauty shop scenes, Gayle Stewart (Marcella) and Ginny Walker (Ruby) were a hoot, trading zingers, and sass with Tammy Smith as the bigoted Jimmie Dean. And rounding out the Bait and Brew gang — Roderick Haynes (U.S.), Mark DiNovo (Frisky), and Barry Smith (Mansel) — each added their own spark to the mix.

All in all, Second Samuel is the kind of show that reminds you why community theatre matters. It makes you laugh, makes you think, and makes you feel connected — to the characters, to the town, and to each other.

If this production is any indication, Soda City Theatre has an exciting road ahead. Here’s to a fantastic start and many more stories to come!

Catch Second Samuel at Columbia Soda City Theatre before it’s gone. Performances run November 8, 13-15 at 7:30 pm and on Sunday, Nov. 9 at 3:00 pm. For tickets and more information, please visit their website at sodacitytheatre.com.

REVIEW: Chapin Theatre Company's 10 Minute-ish Play Festival

By Cindi Boiter

I wish I could tell you that if you’re looking for a fun time in the theatre this weekend you should make your way out to Chapin Theatre Company’s new space for the 5th year of their 10 Minute-ish Play Festival. But it would all be a tease unless you’re one of the lucky folks who grabbed a ticket to one of the upcoming three performances before they completely sold out! And THAT alone is a big enough hint to tell you how fun and entertaining this sequence of performances is!

Produced by Lou Clyde and Jim DeFelice, CTC’s 10 Minute-ish Play Festival offers the audience a total of 8 short plays written by SC playwrights and directed and performed by some of the stalwarts of the greater Midlands theatre arts community. Selected from close to 50 scripts submitted before May 31st, these eight plays are clever, innovative, and almost always funny. Playwrights include Jonathan Cook, Lou Clyde, Rae Kostal, MonaLisa T. Botts, Glen Farr, AKR Scott, Eduardo Oliviera, and Susan Demchak with directors Jerry Crouch, Elizabeth Stepp Oliviera, Debra Leopard, Glen Farr, MonaLisa T. Botts, Jane Peterson, and Ivy Munnerlyn.

This reviewer had the pleasure of attending the dress rehearsal for the production Thursday night. It was my first time in CTC’s new space at 830 Columbia Avenue on the way into Chapin where the house was fairly full, considering it was a rehearsal. The space itself says a lot about the perseverance of Jim DeFelice and his board of directors and patrons. (Aside - In an article coming up in the fall issue of the print version of Jasper Magazine,  releasing on Saturday November 8th at Gemini Arts in Columbia, Jane Peterson explores the history of CTC, the conversion from Chapin Community Theatre to its current form, and more, stay tuned to learn more about the tireless dedication of this organization.)

The evening began with the hilarious Don’t Call Me Cupid, written by Cook and directed by Munnerlyn, featuring Hannah Peak, Tyler Zangla, David LaTorre, and Allison Allgood, whose exemplary work shows up in a total of three of the evening’s plays. DeFelice and Clyde made the right decision in opening the fest with Cupid. It’s funny, irreverent, and outside-the-box, setting the stage aptly for the evening to come.

Lou Clyde’s Heartbeat was next up, directed by Jane Peterson and featuring such  a strong performance by Tiffany Dinsmore that I don’t want to miss her next show. Dinsmore demonstrated a wide range of emotions and responses in this very sweet look at pregnancy and family.

Rae Kostal’s Offsides followed, cleverly turning societal expectations of romance and gender orientation on its head and bringing into question institutional biases many of us still adhere to. It was great to see Emily Harrill, who typically works as stage manager actually ON the stage and, again, Allison Allgood was strong, as was Abby Mathias.

Without a doubt, the funniest play of the evening was Taking Care of Business written and directed by MonaLisa T. Botts, who also played the character of Diane. But it was Debra Kiser who stole the show  with her performance of Grace, a dry-witted woman who had been wronged and, though hilariously inebriated, was taking matters into her own hands delivering lines in her best Southern drawl like, “He’s just got a bad case of lead poisoning because he’s got a bullet in him.”

Perhaps the most innovative script of the evening came from writer and director Glen Farr with his futuristic, I’m Dead, Jim. Featuring Frank Thompson, Barry Smith, Will Dowd, and Katie Mixon, I’m Dead, Jim is smart, well written, well directed, and right on the cusp of the reality/illusion divide where we tend to find ourselves these days as humanity contemplates potential new dimensions of existence. Like a brief and comical episode of Black Mirror, Farr was right on the money in offering audiences this play at this time.

Though at times following the arc of the play Sticky-Fingered Sailor by A.K.R. Scott was a little challenging, I was delighted to be introduced to Thurayya UmBayemake in the role of Esme, playing opposite David LaTorre as Jack. UmBayemake is a joy to watch, particularly in this very sweet tale, directed by Debra Leopard.

The Princess and the King, a tale of love and manipulation featuring Barry Smith as an Elvis impersonator, Christy Mills, Mark DiNovo and Len Lesslie, was written by Susan Demchak and directed by Jerry Crouch. With more moving pieces than the other plays, Demchak’s script also gave us the surprise ending that characterized most of the plays in the second half of the production. While Mills was a lot for her colleagues to keep up with, they all rose to the occasion with DiNovo holding his own as a well-dressed thug opposite Mills’ over-the-top camp. And in the end, it worked!

Easily my favorite play of the evening, Debt, written by Eduardo Oliveira and directed by Elizabeth Stepp Oliveira, was  the more serious of the festival’s plays and it gave us the best actors’ performances with Scott Stepp as Jerry Wakefield and Allison Allgood as his wife, Beth. While limited to 10minutes-ish, Debt was tight and succinct but it told a tale that could easily be expanded into a full-length play. It almost felt like what we saw was condensed from a lengthier piece and done so expertly. Kudos to the Oliveiras, Stepp, and Allgood, all of whom got my vote for best play and actors. (There is actually a ballot on which audience members can cast these votes.)  

This review would be remiss if we didn’t mention the stellar performance of the emcee for the evening, George Dinsmore. During what appeared to be off-the-cuff riffs between plays but were surely pre-planned, Dinsmore kept the audience entertained and looking as forward to his interludes as we did to the plays themselves. He was charming, entertaining, and thoughtfully humble, never making the show about him as the emcee—something we rarely see in theatre, but something to be appreciated and recognized when we do.

Congratulations to the 30-plus theatre artists of Chapin Theatre Company who put this huge production together, including sound and light engineer Simon Marchant, as well as to the smart and on-the-stick patrons who got their tickets while the getting was good!

Chapin Theatre Company’s 5th annual 10 Minute-ish Play Festival will be staged tonight and Saturday, August 22nd and 23rd at 7:30 pm and Sunday August 24th at 3 pm at 830 Columbia Avenue. For more information on CTC check out their website and look forward to their next production, Dracula: A Comedy of Terrors October 3 – 19, directed by George Dinsmore and featuring Frank Thompson, David Fichter, Katie Mixon, and Debra Kiser with Josh Kern as Dracula.